Halperin Grades the New Hampshire Debate

Romney

Style: A much different presence, deliberately, than in the 2008 debates -- less awkward, coldfishy, and show-offy, with a sharper viewpoint and a more natural and leaderlike sensibility. Avoided the fusty, musty old-fashioned language he habitually employs. Announced Bruins 4-0 hockey lead with more charm than he usually demonstrates in public.

Substance: Missed a chance to further distinguish himself from his rivals by failing to offer solutions along with his critique of Obama’s policies. Did not explain with any specificity how he would better handle the economy than the president.

The worst point: Twisted himself in a bit of a rhetorical pretzel trying to explain his past statements about the Detroit auto bailout. Also: There was distracting perspiration on upper lip from the get go, and he looked unusually tired—if still movie-idol handsome.

The best point: Calmly and clearly handled RomneyCare versus ObamaCare. For the foreseeable future: asked and answered.

The main thing: Took a page from Hillary Clinton’s 2007 playbook by agreeing with his Republican competitors whenever he could and pivoting to attack the other party’s incumbent president. The best news of the night for his supporters: rivals took a pass on invitations to go after him on health care and abortion flip-flopping. Leaves St. Anselm even stronger than he entered.

GRADE: A-

Candidate grades are based on both performance and success in using the debate to improve their standing in the nomination contest.