Evening News Roundup

All three programs began with fallout from the N.Y. Times story on McCain.   ABC: Weaknesses in the NYT story led the program—no evidence, unnamed sources, etc., setting consistently skeptical tone. Report said McCain was “serene” and his wife “stood by her man” in response. Said aide Weaver claimed he asked lobbyist to stop bragging about her access, not to stop a relationship. Second package said story raised questions about the NYT, showed Limbaugh’s criticisms, mentioned New Republic story and quoted skeptical media critics. Stephanopoulos reviewed new Democratic poll numbers.   Back-of-the-envelope calculations: 30% facts of the story and reaction, 60% scrutiny of the Times, 10% right wing rallying to McCain.   CBS: Led with McCain’s reaction to story, detailed the facts. Journalism expert Tom Rosenstiel appeared skeptical. Report mentioned Keating Five scandal (with video) and McCain’s “good government” work. Clip of Limbaugh blasting Times, claim that campaign believes they weathered the storm. Moving to Democrats, mention of Obama winning overseas ballots, report previewing Texas debate. Jeff Greenfield said Clinton faces serious problems, Bob Schieffer said the Times story may have helped McCain among conservatives.   Back-of-the-envelope calculations: 40% facts of the story and reaction, 30% scrutiny of the Times, 30% right wing rallying to McCain.   NBC: Led with "the shot heard round the political world" -- the McCain NYT controversy. Said he's "fighting for his own reputation," mostly recapped facts. Then, turned to Dems (noting they were "all but drowned out" by McCain story). Highlighted Clinton pushing for votes in Texas' tight race, Obama's growing support, Roy Spence saying state is high stakes. Russert weighed in, said McCain camp "successfully" pushed back against NYT. Noted Obama is +20 superdelegates since Feb. 5, Clinton is -4.   Back-of-the-envelope calculation: 70% facts of the story and reaction, 20% scrutiny of the Times, 10% right wing rallying to McCain